A Comprehensive Guide to Gain Staging, Recording, Mixing, and Mastering Levels for Classical Guitarists
Part I - Gain Staging & Recording Recording
As we, classical guitarists, have ventured into the world of recording, we've faced the intriguing challenge of capturing our instrument's perfect sound. After meticulously learning about different microphones, mastering the art of microphone arrays, and optimizing our room for the ideal recording tone, we often feel ready to immortalize our masterpiece. Yet, beneath this readiness lies a vast universe of elements that we need to fine-tune to achieve an optimal recording. Among these, understanding gain staging, recording levels, mixing, and mastering levels is crucial.
While there's a plethora of information available on the internet, it can often feel like trying to find our way through an intricate maze, riddled with confusing technical jargon and conflicting advice. In light of this, I've decided to consolidate my personal insights, specific tips, and favorite tools into this comprehensive guide. My aim is to shed some light on these crucial aspects and assist you in capturing and polishing your classical guitar recordings to perfection.
dB Trivia
But first, we have to familiarize ourselves with decibels or dB. These logarithmic units are used to measure the intensity of audio signals. The world of digital audio can be treacherous if you're not careful - one misstep could lead to clipping or distortion, which occurs when the audio signal exceeds 0 dBFS (decibels relative to full scale). Attention to detail is pivotal.
Recording Levels & Gain Staging: Laying the Foundation for a Great Recording
The journey to a great recording begins with understanding gain staging. Gain staging is a process that ensures a clean, distortion-free recording while leaving enough breathing room for further processing during post-production. This involves setting optimal levels of audio signals at each stage of your recording chain. In the context of home studios, this often involves just your instrument, an audio interface, and perhaps some ITB (In The Box) processing.
However, even in this simplified chain, ensuring good gain staging remains crucial. This starts with the sound of your instrument in the room. You'll need to ensure your guitar's sound is clear, resonant, and free from any unwanted noise or interference. Careful placement of the microphones is also key.
Each microphone and each placement will give a different color and character to your recording. When setting up my microphones, I experiment with different placements and distances. Finding the sweet spot is an art - it should capture the guitar's natural tone while minimizing room noise. Adjusting the distance and angle of your microphones can help control not only the tone but also the levels: too close and the sound might be overly loud or boomy; too far and the signal could be weak, leading to a noise-prone recording when amplified. Have a look at my Stereo Microphone Techniques for the Classical Guitar guide..
The next step in the chain is the audio interface. This is where the acoustic energy, the sound waves your guitar produces and your microphones capture, are converted into digital signals your computer can understand.
Your audio interface typically has preamps which amplify the microphone's signal to a level suitable for the Analog to Digital Converter (ADC). The gain knob on your interface controls this amplification. It's crucial to find the right balance here: a signal that's too weak may introduce noise when you try to increase the volume later, while a signal that's too strong risks clipping, distorting your guitar's natural sound.
Once gain staging is properly set, the next crucial part of the process is managing your recording levels. Recording levels refer to the strength or amplitude of the audio signals being recorded in your DAW. In other words, it’s about how loud the recorded audio will be.
For classical guitar, I aim for an average level (or RMS level) around -18 dBFS to -12 dBFS, with peaks not exceeding -6 dBFS. This ensures a healthy signal level without risking distortion or clipping. These values might not mean much if you're just starting out, but understanding them and using a metering tool to monitor your levels will make a big difference in the quality of your recordings.
For those of you who, like me, prefer to use an external preamp along with a separate ADC, the gain staging process involves an additional step but the principle remains the same. Using an external preamp like the AEA TRP2 or SPL Crescendo duo, allows for even more control over the tonal characteristics and the level of the signal coming from your microphones.
Once the signal is conditioned by the preamp, it then goes into a separate ADC, such as the RME ADI-2 Pro FS in my case, which converts the analog signal into digital. Adjusting the input level on the ADC is equally crucial as on the audio interface's preamp for those who use an integrated solution. The goal is the same - ensuring a healthy signal level without risking distortion or clipping, which for me is around -18 dBFS to -12 dBFS RMS, with peaks not exceeding -6 dBFS.
This might seem like an extra layer of complexity, but in my experience, the flexibility and control provided by separate high-quality preamps and ADCs can lead to even better results, and it's worth considering if you're serious about recording.
To sum up, good gain staging for a classical guitar recording involves capturing a clean signal from your guitar, through the air, into your microphones, then into your audio interface, and finally into your DAW. Each step requires careful attention, but with practice and patience, the results can be immensely rewarding.
Additional Tips for Optimal Gain Staging:
I mainly use Vovox Sonorous and Sommer Epilogue cables for a peace of mind
Starting with a Clean Signal: The quest for the perfect recording begins long before hitting the record button. I ensure that my guitar is properly set up and my strings are in good condition to minimize extraneous noise and to allow for effecient dynamics.
High-Quality Cables: Cables can often be overlooked, but they are a critical part of the signal chain. Investing in high-quality cables can prevent unwanted noise and interference in the signal.
Room Acoustics: The room's acoustics can impact the recording significantly. A quiet and sonically balanced room can help ensure a clean, high-quality recording.
Monitoring the Signal Chain: Vigilance is key throughout the recording process. By continuously monitoring the levels throughout my recording chain, I can prevent unexpected overloads or distortions and ensure the best quality recording.
Using Metering Tools for Precision
Youlean Loudness Meter is an essential tool
For those of us who want to be precise with our levels, I highly recommend using metering tools. One of my favorite tools is the Youlean Loudness Meter. This handy software allows me to monitor not only the loudness of my recording but also the dynamic range. The free version is good enough for most cases, and you can support the developers by purchasing the pro version which provides some additional features.
Maintaining Dynamic Control
Classical guitar's essence lies in its subtleties and nuances. Dynamics - the interplay between the quietest and loudest notes, crescendos, decrescendos - bring the music to life, allowing your listeners to connect more deeply.
When setting my recording levels, I always leave ample headroom for these dynamics, striking a balance so that the louder sections don't cause distortion or clipping and the quieter parts remain clear and noise-free. Remember, amplifying a quiet, clean recording is always preferable to fixing a loud, distorted one.
Additionally, transient details - quick, high-energy moments - require careful attention to avoid distortion or getting lost in the mix. Proper recording levels ensure these moments are accurately captured, adding to the richness of the final recording.
Striking the Right Tone
In conclusion, understanding and managing recording levels, along with proper gain staging, can make a significant difference in capturing a perfect performance. It can be the difference between a recording that sounds amateur and one that stands up to professional scrutiny. With careful attention to detail, patience, and practice, you'll be on your way to making recordings that you can be proud of.
Stay tuned for Part II of this series, where we'll dive deeper into the realm of audio recording as we explore the importance of levels in the post-production stages - mixing and mastering. This is where your carefully recorded tracks are polished into a cohesive, balanced, and compelling final product. Until then, happy recording!
A Beginner's Guide to Home Recording for Classical Guitarists
Home recording technology has come a long way in recent years, and it's now easier than ever for classical guitarists to record high-quality audio from the comfort of their own home. If you are a classical guitarist looking to record your music at home, you may be wondering where to start. In this beginner's guide, I will go over the essential tools and techniques you'll need to get started with home recording for classical guitarists. From choosing the right microphone and recording software to setting up a recording space and editing and producing your tracks, I will cover everything you need to know.
Choosing the Right Equipment
The first step in setting up a home recording studio for classical guitar is choosing the right equipment. There are a few key pieces of equipment that every home recording studio should have:
Microphones: A good pair of microphones is essential for recording the classical guitar. There are many different types of microphones to choose from, each with unique characteristics. I often like to employ large diaphragm condensers for their low self-noise.
Read the buyer's guide on the Best Microphones for Classical Guitar.
Audio interface: An audio interface is a device that connects your microphones to your computer, allowing you to record audio digitally. Besides, an audio interface allows you to connect your headphones and studio monitors.
Read the buyer's guide on the Best Audio Interfaces for Classical Guitar.
Studio Monitors: Studio monitors are specialized speakers that are designed for use in recording studios. They differ from regular home speakers in that they have a relatively flat frequency response without boosting or attenuating any particular frequency. Studio Monitors are ideal for mixing and mastering music, as they allow you to hear the true sound of your recordings.
Read the buyer's guide on the Best Studio Monitors for Classical Guitar.
Headphones: Headphones are an important part of any home recording setup, as they allow you to hear all the nuances in your playing and recordings. I prefer open headphones for mixing, editing and music listening, while closed headphones are necessary if you want to do overdubs.
Setting up a Recording Space
Once you have the necessary equipment, the next step is to set up a recording space that will allow you to produce high-quality audio. Here are a few things to consider:
Acoustics: The acoustics of your recording space will have an immense impact on the sound of your recordings. A room with decent acoustics will produce a balanced and natural sound, while a room with poor acoustics can produce a boomy sound and introduce flutter echo to your recordings. To improve the acoustics of your recording space, you can use acoustic treatment products such as acoustic panels, bass traps and diffusers to absorb or diffuse sound waves.
If you are on a tight budget, you can read my post on Three Ways to Improve your Recording Space Without Spending Any Money.
Organization: Keep your recording space organized and ready to use at any time. This means having all your equipment in position and easy reach, so you don't have to spend time searching for things when you want to record. Furthermore, a cluttered and disorganized space can be distracting and make it difficult to focus on your playing. By setting up your room in a functional and organized way, you'll be able to focus on your playing and create better recordings.
Lighting: Good lighting will set the mood and create a comfortable practising recording environment. Natural light is usually the best choice, but if you don't have access to natural light, you can use artificial lighting to create a similar effect.
Getting Started with Recording Software
Once you have your equipment and recording space set up, the next step is to choose recording software. There are many different options available, ranging from free software with basic features to professional-grade software with advanced capabilities. Some popular DAW (Digital Audio Workstations) for recording classical guitar include:
Audacity is a free, open-source recording software popular with many classical guitarists. It offers a range of basic recording and editing features and is easy to use especially for beginners.
Apple GarageBand is a digital audio workstation that comes pre-installed on many Apple computers. It offers a range of basic recording and editing features and is suitable for beginners.
Apple Logic Pro is a professional-grade recording software widely used by music producers. It offers a wide range of advanced features and includes the most complete library of virtual instruments and a comprehensive set of plugin effects of any DAW.
Steinberg Cubase is another professional-grade recording software and a great alternative to Logic Pro if you are a Windows user. Cubase Elements is powerful enough for most classical guitarist applications and is affordable for those just getting started on recording.
Recording Techniques
Once you have your equipment and software set up, you are out of excuses; it's time to start recording! Here are a few tips for achieving the best sound from your classical guitar recordings:
Experiment with microphone placement: The position of the microphones relative to the guitar will have a huge impact on the sound of your recordings.
For a detailed description of various microphone techniques, read my post on Stereo Microphone Techniques for the Classical Guitar.
Set up the gain on your audio interface: The gain control on your audio interface determines the level at which your guitar is recorded. Set the gain to a level that avoids clipping (distortion) or a weak signal. Set the peaks (loudest parts) to reach around at around -6dB, so that you'll have plenty of headroom.
Have the right mindset for recording: An often overlooked aspect of the recording is the mindset and mood you bring to the recording. Be relaxed and focused when recording, so that you can capture the best performance possible. Take breaks as needed to ensure that you are feeling fresh and energized.
For more suggestions, read my post on 5+1 Things You Should Do Before You Press the RECORD Button, from the perspective of a Classical Guitarist.
Editing and Producing Your Recordings
Once you've recorded your classical guitar tracks, the next step is to edit and produce your recordings to create a professional-sounding final result. Here are a few things to consider:
Be conservative with editing: Editing audio has become pretty simple, but too much editing makes your recordings end up sounding lifeless.
Use plugin effects wisely: While it's necessary to use EQ and Reverb plugins to fine-tune your recorded sound, create the right mood for your music, and enhance the sound of your tracks. Try not to overprocess the recording. Aim for a natural sound for your solo classical guitar music. For further information on plugins, read my post Three Most Essential Plugins for the Classical Guitar.
Set the levels correctly: Make sure that the volume of your music is loud enough but doesn't clip (distort) the outputs. Leaving about 1 dB of headroom is a good practice.
Exporting your music: When you're happy with your produced recordings, it's time to export them as a final audio file. Make sure to save your tracks in a high-quality format, such as WAV or AIFF, to preserve the sound quality of your recordings.
Conclusion
In conclusion, recording your music at home can be a rewarding and fulfilling experience, and it's easier than ever to get started with the right equipment and software. By following the tips and techniques outlined in this guide, you'll be well on your way to creating recordings you can be proud of.
Three Ways to Improve your Recording Space Without Spending Any Money
Let’s talk about the room - Part I
When we think about improving our recorded sound, we usually think about upgrades in gear; we lust for new microphones, interfaces, guitars, etc. We don't want to buy new things; we absolutely need them. Sometimes, we even postpone recording altogether until we have the budget for purchasing said gear.
The harsh truth that we sometimes don't want to admit is that spending more money on gear will not fix fundamental issues. Getting a good sound in the room before we hit record is essential, as essentially, this is the sound that our microphones hear and our interfaces capture. Fix it in the mix does not apply with classical guitar recordings wherein room and performer are equally exposed.
Having used all sorts of gear in all possible situations, I rank all the elements of the recording chain in this order: guitarist, guitar, room, microphones, engineer, playback system, post-production skills, preamps, converters, cables. Leaving everything else aside, in this article, I examine a few ways to get the best out of a typical residential room without spending any money.
Disclaimer - room treatment can be approached from a more technical standpoint which I plan to discuss here in the future. Contrarily to what the vendors of acoustic panels will say, household items can be used as a pragmatic alternative, even more so considering the singular commitment of a classical guitar recording space.
First. The sitting position.
Sometimes out of being lazy or just practical, we set up everything as is and keep the room as we would normally use it, especially if we don't have a dedicated music room. Considering the degree that the room affects the recorded sound, searching for a suitable sitting position should not be overlooked.
Before all else, when I enter a new space for a session, I try to figure out the best sounding position in the room. This habit applies both for on-location to home recordings and even concerts to some degree. I'm not getting into detail about on-location recordings and big spaces now, as this goes beyond the purpose of this text.
I have assembled a few guidelines to help you search for the perfect sitting position in your room but keep in mind that every room has unique sound properties.
First of all, you want to avoid sitting close to the walls and most definitely steer clear of the corners; the build-up of low frequencies and the early reflections will cloud the direct sound of the guitar. Also, the centre of the room is far from an ideal sitting position, especially in a room with parallel walls.
In an ordinary rectangular room, if possible, you'd want to sit alongside the long walls about three-fourths to two-thirds of the length of the room. In addition, I find that sitting a bit off-centre and facing the front wall at a slight angle towards the longest distance produces the best results; this modest break of symmetry helps.
Nonetheless, you need to experiment with your space as every room is different. Perhaps asking someone else to play your guitar in a couple of different positions and try to listen is not a bad idea. If this is not possible, pay attention to the sound while you play; singing can also assist you in identifying the room modes. Moreover, you'll need to record yourself in various spots and listen critically; recording the same piece can make comparisons less ambiguous.
What you are looking for is the most balanced sound; play all notes of your guitar in sequence as well as your favourite piece, and if it gets boomy or any frequency stands out a lot, try a few different angles or move a little. If the room is untreated, which probably is, the result will not be outstanding, but in any case, it is worth finding the position where standing waves are not encouraged, then acoustic treatment can be employed.
Second. Other uses for your books.
Speaking of acoustic treatment, this goes without saying, at least to some extent. But, as our rooms usually serve (at least) a dual purpose, a playing/recording space along with a listening/production room, some compromises have to be made. Critical listening requires a controlled environment, while what makes a good room for recording acoustic instruments can be partially subjective.
I have recorded in all sorts of situations, from big halls with a vast reverberation to heavily treated studios with no ambience at all as well as everything in between, thus I have concluded that I genuinely don't enjoy playing in an acoustically dead room. Even if the captured sound in such a controlled room is somewhat easier to handle, the performance and feel of the music always take a big hit. Clever microphone placement and good post-production skills can make almost any room sound acceptable, contrary there is nothing we can do to improve an uninspiring performance.
Thankfully, the classical guitar is not the loudest instrument around, with a lot of its energy residing is in the mids and highs, so it is not impossible to minimize the small room sound signature. Whilst is more convenient to record at home, on-location recording is never out of the question; I could always visit one of the exceptional sounding halls in Berlin or elsewhere when absolute sound is required. It is also refreshing to work on other rooms.
Wherein large rooms we have to deal with diffuse sound fields, which pose their challenges anyway, small rooms suffer from early reflections and resonances associated with standing waves. Dealing with the low frequencies below 300Hz is rather troublesome as wavelengths are large and spread omnidirectionally, while higher frequencies behave more like rays.
The key here is to use a combination of diffusion and absorption strategically. Since broadband diffusers and absorbers can get expensive fast and need to be quite thick to have any effect at the low-mid and low frequencies, there is a free alternative you can use effectively: books.
Books placed on shelves create an uneven surface, forming some sort of diffuser from which sound waves are reflected in different directions. Moreover, paper absorbs some of the sound energy, so a bookshelf works in addition as an absorber.
Gather your books and build a bookshelf on the front-facing wall (in the typical control room, the front wall is considered the one where the monitors are placed, here I use the term to indicate the wall you face when you play your guitar). Use different book sizes and thicknesses, and experiment on the relative depths; this bookshelf will absorb and scatter the sound in the room while maintaining some liveliness.
Admittingly, a bookshelf won't do much to the lower frequencies, and its properties will be somewhat random. However, you probably have plenty of books in your household already, and a bookshelf is more eye-pleasing. Plus, they are nice to read from time to time.
Third. The floor.
Since the guitar hangs in closer proximity to the floor than any other reflective surface around you, bouncing frequencies would cloud the direct sound. Also, the somewhat low ceilings and small dimensions of residential rooms dictate for closer and lower microphone positioning that say a concert hall, thus heightening the problem.
To tame the room ambience to a certain degree, place a rug between your guitar and the microphones. Avoid covering the whole room with a carpet, but rather use a small to medium-sized one.
Experiment with a few different sizes and thicknesses until you find what works in your space. Your goal is to allow the microphones to capture a cleaner sound while maintaining the room ambience. The absorption will only be effective at the high frequencies. I use a woollen rug of medium thickness that extends from just under my seating position to a bit further than the position of the microphone stand.
Closing
With the advancement in technology over the last twenty years, quality recording equipment has become pretty affordable consequently capturing compelling recordings at home is no longer impossible. However, we should not forget that the microphones capture the sound of our guitars in our rooms. So, be intentional and learn trust your ears.